Make Housing Tax Fair Across Generations
Replace the 50% Capital Gains Tax discount with inflation indexation of the cost base for newly acquired assets, and apply stricter CGT treatment to investment housing so gains reflect real value creation rather than a tax-favoured windfall.
- Proposed by
- Fusion Working Group
- Applies to
- Fusion NationalAuthority: Fusion National
- Ballot wording
- Original recorded wording · 27 Oct 20268 ballots cast · 1 contribution
- Policy Registry
- Not yet adoptedUpdated
Key commitments
Younger Australians will face a fairer market when competing with tax-advantaged capital gains strategies.
Investment returns will reflect real gains after inflation rather than an automatic discount.
Capital will flow more readily toward productive investment when housing is less tax-favoured as a wealth vehicle.
Public revenue will strengthen as large untaxed gains are reduced in the base.
Speculative “buy-and-hold for the discount” strategies will lose their edge as preferential treatment is removed.
Rationale & background
Rationale & background
Design rationale
Australia moved from CGT indexation to a flat discount model in 1999. Indexation targets the core fairness question—taxing real gains rather than inflation—without granting an automatic windfall discount unrelated to inflation.
Indexation precedent and current-law context
For certain pre-1999 assets, Australian tax law still allows indexation as an alternative to the discount, demonstrating that indexation is an established concept in the system.
Structural limits
- For assets acquired after the start date, the CGT discount is not available; the cost base is indexed for inflation using a defined indexation factor.
- Investment housing receives the tightened treatment first, reflecting its outsized role in speculation incentives.
- Transitional treatment is defined by acquisition date (grandfathering rules) to avoid retroactive taxation shocks.
- Integrity rules apply to prevent asset re-characterisation and wash-sale behaviour around the start date.
Evidence and live policy discussion
Recent Parliamentary Budget Office costing work explicitly models replacing the CGT discount with cost-base indexation for non-property assets while removing the discount for investment properties under defined conditions, indicating indexation is being actively considered in contemporary reform design.
Risk and failure modes
Risks include lock-in effects if poorly designed, or loopholes that preserve the discount’s effect through alternative concessions. Success depends on tight start-date rules and integrity provisions.
Implementation outline
CGT discount provisions, indexation factor definitions, transitional acquisition-date rules, and compliance guidance would be updated to support consistent application.
Member ballot
What you’re deciding
Replace the 50% Capital Gains Tax discount with inflation indexation of the cost base for newly acquired assets, and apply stricter CGT treatment to investment housing so gains reflect real value creation rather than a tax-favoured windfall.
Review commitmentsBallot record
Wording: Original recorded wording · 27 Oct 2026
How many people need to vote?
Quorum metEngage needs at least 30 eligible registered members before its ballots can make decisions. Each ballot also needs enough people to take part.
- Eligible registered members
- 37 · platform quorum met
- Recently active members
- 14 in the last 90 days
- Participants needed
- 7
- Votes recorded so far
- 8 of 7 needed
You can vote for, vote against or abstain. All three count towards participation. The final calculation happens when voting closes, so the number needed can change as members become active or inactive.
8 votes have been recorded. Sign in to vote if you are eligible.
Your vote is identifiable to national administrators and authorised national ballot reviewers. Aggregate results are public; a very small ballot may reveal individual choices. Privacy Policy
Formal amendments
0Suggest exact changes to a title, summary, commitment or rationale paragraph. Voting on an amendment is separate from voting on the main proposal.
No formal amendments have been proposed yet.
Discussion
1 contributionShare evidence, ask a question or suggest an improvement. Discussion scores do not count as ballot votes.
"apply stricter CGT treatment to investment housing" − people don't pay any capital gains tax for owner-occupied dwellings; the 50% discount is only for "investment housing", so it's not clear where you're meant to apply this "stricter" treatment than the revision of the 50% to the indexed inflation. This policy proposal also fails to mention our existing policy about capital gains tax, or its rationale, so for that alone I am voting against it.
Verified members can sign in to comment or vote on contributions.
Wording history and sources
1 snapshotSee how the wording has changed and which version was put to a ballot. References below provide background; they do not by themselves establish prior adoption.
- Original recorded wording · 27 Oct 2026
legacy-1LatestBallot wording
Policy background and sources
References to earlier policy and notes about what is known of its history.
Adapts or expands prior Fusion policy, submissions, or state-level positions with new or materially revised mechanisms.
Prior policy predecessors
- Housing as a Home ↗ — Direct predecessor for reducing housing CGT concessions; the replacement of the discount with inflation indexation is a new design.
Values & principles alignment
- Principle: *Inclusive Economic Advancement* — Less preferential capital-gains treatment reduces tax-driven disparities between housing investors and other households.
- Value: *Equity* — Removing preferential treatment reduces the advantage held by people who already own investment housing.
"apply stricter CGT treatment to investment housing" − people don't pay any capital gains tax for owner-occupied dwellings; the 50% discount is only for "investment housing", so it's not clear where you're meant to apply this "stricter" treatment than the revision of the 50% to the indexed inflation. This policy proposal also fails to mention our existing policy about capital gains tax, or its rationale, so for that alone I am voting against it.