SB

Stewart Brooker

Fusion Queensland

Member since 27 Oct 2026

Comments

  1. Amendment1 point

    Commented on Make It Easier to Buy and Move Home

    Protect Households Experiencing Hardship During the Land-Tax Transition Purpose of amendment Support POL-010’s replacement of residential stamp duty with land-value taxation, while protecting eligible homeowners who have substantial equity in their home but insufficient income or accessible savings to meet the annual liability. Retain the existing policy wording, including stamp-duty credits, with the following additions. Transition treatment for households — add Eligible owner-occupiers experiencing financial hardship would have access to full or partial deferral of land-value tax on their principal residence. Eligibility would be assessed against published household income, accessible financial assets and reasonable living-cost criteria. The value of the principal residence alone would not disqualify an applicant. Stamp-duty credits would be applied before determining the amount payable or available for deferral. Deferred liabilities would remain payable and be secured against the property, ordinarily recovered upon sale or transfer. Continuing deferral would be available for an eligible surviving spouse or partner who remains in the home. A temporary absence for health, disability, caring responsibilities or entry into residential care would not automatically terminate eligibility. Published rules would address these circumstances. Tax base guardrails — add Hardship deferral changes the timing of payment, rather than exempting land from taxation or forgiving the liability. It would therefore be compatible with the broad-base requirements and principal-residence guardrails of this policy. The framework would require equivalent minimum hardship protections under both the default federal system and compliant state systems. Risk and failure modes — add Deferral arrangements must balance household security, public revenue and the risk of accumulating debt. Any interest would be transparent, non-punitive and linked to government borrowing costs rather than commercial penalty rates. Additional interest relief would be available in severe hardship under published criteria. Applicants would receive clear statements showing deferred principal, interest and the effect on their remaining equity. Independent review and accessible assistance would be available. Homeowners complying with an approved deferral arrangement would not face forced sale solely to recover the deferred tax. Safeguards would address mortgage interactions, declining equity and potential negative equity. Implementation outline — add Before commencement, publish eligibility criteria, interest arrangements, recovery rules, review rights and protections for surviving partners and temporary absences. Provide a simple application process, accessible support and proportionate reassessment, minimising repeated evidence requirements for households whose circumstances are unlikely to change. Publish estimates of administrative costs, delayed revenue and financing costs. Deferred tax receivables must be reported separately from cash collected. Review the arrangements after the first two years, including household uptake, debt accumulation, administrative burden and whether eligible households can remain securely housed. Effect of the amendment This amendment preserves POL-010’s land-tax base and existing stamp-duty credits. It adds a targeted payment safeguard so eligible households can meet their tax obligations over time without being pushed into selling their home because of immediate cash-flow hardship.

    View comment

  2. Amendment1 point

    Commented on Match Migration to What Australia Can Support

    Strengthen POL-050 with Independent Assessment and a Funded Capacity Plan **Purpose of amendment** Support the existing direction of POL-050 — Match Migration to What Australia Can Support — and add two implementation requirements: • Independent assessment of capacity and migration planning recommendations. • A published government plan to address identified capacity gaps. Retain the existing policy wording, with the following additions. **Framework design — add** “Capacity assessments would be prepared by an appropriately independent existing institution or, where a capability review demonstrates the need, a dedicated Population and Housing Commission. The assessing body would publish annual recommendations, alternative scenarios and a rolling five-year capacity outlook. Its advice would account for existing shortages, other sources of population change and the contribution migrants make to expanding housing and essential service capacity. The choice of institution would be subject to a published assessment of capability, cost and duplication.” **National coordination — add** “Alongside annual migration settings, the federal government would publish a coordinated capacity plan identifying the housing, infrastructure, workforce and essential services required to address existing shortages and projected demand. The plan would identify funded actions, responsible governments or agencies, delivery milestones and remaining unfunded gaps. It would distinguish operational capacity and credibly funded projects from announcements without committed funding.” **Planning discipline — add** “Elected governments would retain responsibility for migration settings and expenditure. Where decisions depart from independent recommendations, government would publish its reasons, supporting evidence and measures to manage identified capacity pressures. Original forecasts, budgets and delivery milestones would remain visible alongside subsequent revisions, allowing the public to compare planning assumptions with actual delivery.” **Implementation outline — add** “Implementation would begin with a review of existing institutional capability and reporting systems. Independent assessments, the government’s response and the corresponding capacity plan would then be published through a common annual review cycle. These requirements would build on existing data and specialist reporting arrangements, minimising duplication and additional administrative work.” **Effect of the amendment** The existing absorptive-capacity framework remains the policy foundation. These additions specify who provides independent advice, how government responds and what governments must deliver to close capacity gaps. They introduce no fixed migration target or automatic intake formula.

    View comment