POL-029Build up Small BusinessesPolicy proposal

Protect Your Privacy from Big Tech

Prohibit the collection, retention, or commercial use of personal data beyond what is strictly necessary to deliver a requested service, and establish enforceable rights to data access, correction, portability, and deletion.

Taking partSign in to save your vote.
  1. Idea
  2. Discussion
  3. Voting
  4. Implementation

Voting is open.

Proposed by
Fusion Working Group
Applies to
Fusion NationalAuthority: Fusion National
Ballot wording
Original recorded wording · 27 Oct 202613 ballots cast · 0 contributions
Policy Registry
Not yet adoptedUpdated

Key commitments

7 commitments
  1. Australians will have more control over how their personal information is collected, used, and retained online.

  2. Small businesses and independent digital services will face less pressure to imitate surveillance-heavy platform models in order to compete.

  3. Consumers will be less exposed to opaque profiling, manipulation, and behavioural targeting built on excessive data extraction.

  4. Digital competition will rely less on who can accumulate the largest hidden data advantage and more on service quality, trust, and user value.

  5. Users will be able to move more easily between services when access, portability, and deletion rights are enforceable in practice.

  6. Market power built on locked-in personal data and accumulated behavioural profiles will become harder for large platforms to defend.

  7. Public confidence in digital services will strengthen when personal data is treated as a constrained input rather than an open-ended commercial asset.

Rationale & background

Rationale & background

Design rationale

Large digital platforms derive structural advantage from collecting and retaining far more personal information than is needed to provide the service the user actually requested. We would shift digital markets away from surveillance-based competition by limiting excess data extraction and giving users enforceable control over the information platforms hold about them.

Data minimisation framework

  1. The central rule is that collection, retention, and commercial use of personal data must be limited to what is strictly necessary to deliver the requested service. This matters because many current platform advantages are built not on better core services but on the ability to convert broad user monitoring into advertising, profiling, and behavioural leverage.
  2. User rights to access, correction, portability, and deletion matter because limiting data extraction alone is not enough where large platforms already hold extensive information and can use retention or lock-in to preserve advantage. The package therefore combines forward limits on data use with rights that let users contest and reduce existing informational asymmetries.

Platform power and competitive effects

  1. Excessive data collection can function as a barrier to competition because large platforms accumulate behavioural insights, targeting capability, and switching friction that smaller firms cannot match without adopting the same extraction model. Constraining that advantage changes the basis of competition from data capture toward service performance and user trust.
  2. Strong portability and deletion rights can reduce lock-in where users would otherwise remain tied to dominant platforms because their history, contacts, preferences, or stored content are difficult to move or meaningfully erase. Those rights are only effective, however, if they are usable in practice rather than nominal rights buried behind slow, opaque, or selective processes.

Risk and failure modes

  1. Large platforms may be expected to reclassify optional data collection as “necessary”, rely on bundled consent, or fragment services so surveillance functions appear operationally indispensable. Integrity depends on whether necessity is defined objectively and enforced against the real function of the service rather than the platform’s preferred business model.
  2. Those rights can also underperform if access, portability, correction, or deletion rights exist formally but are slowed, obscured, or made technically incomplete in practice. Effective privacy reform therefore depends on enforceable standards for response time, data format, scope, and regulator-backed remedies rather than rights that users must negotiate alone.

System interaction

This measure interacts with competition policy, consumer protection, and digital platform regulation, because personal data operates both as a privacy issue and as a structural input that can entrench platform dominance.

Implementation outline

Legislation would define necessity-based collection limits, regulate retention and commercial-use standards, establish enforceable user rights over personal data, set practical standards for portability and deletion, and give regulators power to audit data practices and penalise evasive service design.

Member ballot

Ballot open
What you’re deciding

Prohibit the collection, retention, or commercial use of personal data beyond what is strictly necessary to deliver a requested service, and establish enforceable rights to data access, correction, portability, and deletion.

Review commitments
Ballot record

Wording: Original recorded wording · 27 Oct 2026

How many people need to vote?

Quorum met

Engage needs at least 30 eligible registered members before its ballots can make decisions. Each ballot also needs enough people to take part.

Eligible registered members
37 · platform quorum met
Recently active members
14 in the last 90 days
Participants needed
7
Votes recorded so far
13 of 7 needed

You can vote for, vote against or abstain. All three count towards participation. The final calculation happens when voting closes, so the number needed can change as members become active or inactive.

13 votes have been recorded. Sign in to vote if you are eligible.

Your ballotSelect to preview
Voting closes 8 December 2026

Select Approve, Abstain, or Reject above to start your ballot.

Vote totals

13 verified votes

13 approve · 0 abstain · 0 reject

Your vote is identifiable to national administrators and authorised national ballot reviewers. Aggregate results are public; a very small ballot may reveal individual choices. Privacy Policy

Formal amendments

0

Suggest exact changes to a title, summary, commitment or rationale paragraph. Voting on an amendment is separate from voting on the main proposal.

No formal amendments have been proposed yet.

Discussion

0 contributions

Share evidence, ask a question or suggest an improvement. Discussion scores do not count as ballot votes.

Have a perspective on this proposal?

Verified members can sign in to comment or vote on contributions.

Sign in to participate

No contributions yet. Verified members can start the discussion using the form above.

Wording history and sources

1 snapshot

See how the wording has changed and which version was put to a ballot. References below provide background; they do not by themselves establish prior adoption.

  1. Original recorded wording · 27 Oct 2026legacy-8LatestBallot wording
    27 Oct 2026 · Initial wording

Policy background and sources

References to earlier policy and notes about what is known of its history.

Approved policy predecessor · Equivalence unverified

Cites a direct predecessor on a published Fusion policy page, restructured into Reclaim's 4-tier format; material equivalence of the detailed mechanism wording remains unverified.

Scrutiny note: Links only to a top-level published policy page URL without a clause-level text comparison; Reclaim specifies concrete federal mechanisms that require member review and vote.

Prior policy predecessors

Values & principles alignment

  • Principle: *Digital Privacy & Security* — Limiting exploitative data practices protects people’s control over personal information.