POL-060Update Our SchoolsPolicy proposal
In discussion Decision record

Make NAPLAN Help Students, Not Rank Schools

NAPLAN data-use and reporting rules will be refocused on student diagnosis and system monitoring, with public school comparisons limited to student progress measures, proficiency reporting retained, and students’ absolute achievement levels prohibited as a measure of individual teacher performance.

Taking partVerified members can comment or propose an amendment. Sign in to take part.
  1. Idea
  2. Discussion
  3. Voting
  4. Implementation

Read the discussion, raise a concern, or suggest a wording change before voting begins.

Proposed by
Fusion Working Group
Applies to
Fusion NationalAuthority: Fusion National
Ballot wording
Draft wording (no ballot yet)0 ballots cast · 0 contributions
Policy Registry
Not yet adoptedUpdated

Key commitments

5 commitments
  1. Students will receive a consistent national check of their literacy and numeracy strengths and needs.

  2. Teachers will have assessment data they can use alongside classroom evidence to target learning support.

  3. Teachers will be assessed through professional practice and multiple sources of evidence rather than a single cohort’s test scores.

  4. Parents will have clearer information about how effectively schools help students progress.

  5. Public accountability will focus more closely on student growth and proficiency than on headline school averages.

Rationale & background

Rationale & background

Design rationale

NAPLAN provides a common national measure of literacy and numeracy in Years 3, 5, 7 and 9, and its earlier reporting now gives schools more useful diagnostic information during the school year. ACARA explicitly states that NAPLAN is a snapshot, should be considered alongside other assessment evidence, and is not designed to measure teacher or school performance in isolation.

My School nevertheless publishes school-average NAPLAN results and comparisons with students of similar backgrounds and national results. ACARA itself warns that NAPLAN represents only one aspect of school performance and has repeatedly criticised out-of-context school league tables as misleading. The problem is therefore not national testing or school comparison itself, but treating students’ absolute achievement as a measure of what a school has contributed to their learning.

Assessment purpose

NAPLAN would remain a national literacy and numeracy assessment, with individual results available to students, families, teachers, and schools. Education authorities would retain the data needed to identify learning gaps, allocate support, evaluate programs, and monitor performance across regions and demographic groups.

Teacher assessment

NAPLAN results could contribute to teacher performance and development where they provide relevant evidence about student learning. This may include growth by the same students between successive NAPLAN assessments, but may never rely on students’ absolute achievement levels.

Longitudinal growth still cannot be attributed cleanly to an individual teacher. Students pass through multiple teachers between NAPLAN assessments, literacy and numeracy develop across subjects and school-wide programs, and factors outside a teacher’s control continue to affect progress. NAPLAN growth data may therefore contribute to teacher assessment only alongside classroom assessment, professional practice, observation, student work, and other evidence of learning, and must never be converted into an automatic teacher-performance score. This is consistent with the existing Australian Teacher Performance and Development Framework, which requires teacher evaluation to draw on multiple sources of evidence.

Public reporting

My School would continue to provide comparable information about school performance, but public comparisons would be limited to student progress measures. Absolute proficiency information would remain available to show whether students are meeting national standards, but would not be used to rank schools.

Progress comparisons would account for students’ starting achievement and relevant background characteristics, building on the matched-student progress measures My School already uses.

Residual limits

NAPLAN measures literacy and numeracy at particular points in time and cannot capture the full educational progress of a student or the overall quality of a school. Even contextualised progress measures cannot perfectly isolate the contribution of teaching from family circumstances, student characteristics, attendance, and other influences. National testing should therefore remain one source of evidence rather than becoming a complete measure of educational quality.

Implementation outline

National assessment and reporting arrangements would be updated through the Education Ministers Meeting and ACARA so public school comparisons use student progress measures rather than average achievement scores, while individual and system-level diagnostic uses of NAPLAN are retained. Teacher performance frameworks and funding agreements would prohibit the use of students’ absolute achievement levels as a measure of individual teacher performance.

Reference

National Assessment Program: Literacy and Numeracy | Australian Teacher Performance and Development Framework | Using value-added measures to identify school contributions to student learning

Member ballot

Not yet open
What you’re deciding

NAPLAN data-use and reporting rules will be refocused on student diagnosis and system monitoring, with public school comparisons limited to student progress measures, proficiency reporting retained, and students’ absolute achievement levels prohibited as a measure of individual teacher performance.

Review commitments
Ballot record

Wording: Draft wording (no ballot yet)

Formal voting has not opened yet. Join the discussion or propose a wording amendment while this proposal is in deliberation.

Your vote is identifiable to national administrators and authorised national ballot reviewers. Aggregate results are public; a very small ballot may reveal individual choices. Privacy Policy

Formal amendments

0

Suggest exact changes to a title, summary, commitment or rationale paragraph. Voting on an amendment is separate from voting on the main proposal.

No formal amendments have been proposed yet.

Discussion

0 contributions

Share evidence, ask a question or suggest an improvement. Discussion scores do not count as ballot votes.

Have a perspective on this proposal?

Verified members can sign in to comment or vote on contributions.

Sign in to participate

No contributions yet. Verified members can start the discussion using the form above.

Wording history and sources

1 snapshot

See how the wording has changed and which version was put to a ballot. References below provide background; they do not by themselves establish prior adoption.

  1. Original recorded wording · 27 Oct 2026legacy-fLatest
    27 Oct 2026 · Initial wording

Policy background and sources

References to earlier policy and notes about what is known of its history.

Flagged 'New' in static export · Lineage unverified

Badged 'New — pending AGM vote' in the Reclaim static export (/pending-vote/), but outside the 36-policy AGM Round 1 lineage dataset.

Scrutiny note: No clause-by-clause audit against prior approved Fusion policy pages has been recorded in the repository for this domain.