POL-024Fix the Tax ExploitsPolicy proposal
In discussion Decision record

Make Carbon Compliance Real

Require large polluters to buy and surrender one high-integrity carbon credit for every tonne of emissions, and prohibit rules that allow weak, over-issued, or self-generated credits to dilute the system and avoid real emissions costs.

Taking partVerified members can comment or propose an amendment. Sign in to take part.
  1. Idea
  2. Discussion
  3. Voting
  4. Implementation

Read the discussion, raise a concern, or suggest a wording change before voting begins.

Proposed by
Fusion Working Group
Applies to
Fusion NationalAuthority: Fusion National
Ballot wording
Draft wording (no ballot yet)0 ballots cast · 0 contributions
Policy Registry
Not yet adoptedUpdated

Key commitments

5 commitments
  1. Every tonne of pollution will carry a real and unavoidable cost.

  2. Only credits backed by genuine, measurable, and lasting carbon sequestration will count for compliance.

  3. Companies will not be able to create credits within their own corporate group and use them to cancel out their own pollution.

  4. Credit supply will grow only when additional carbon is genuinely removed and durably stored.

  5. The carbon market will reward real decarbonisation instead of accounting workarounds.

Rationale & background

Rationale & background

Design rationale

Australia already requires major facilities to account for emissions but there are weaknesses and liability is not total. In a proper full-liability system, every tonne emitted must be matched with a credit. The strength of the system depends entirely on the integrity and scarcity of those credits.

If credits do not represent real and lasting carbon sequestration, polluters can meet their liability without an equivalent amount of carbon being removed from the atmosphere.

Core integrity rules

  1. One tonne emitted requires surrender of one eligible Australian credit each quarter, with no discount pathways.
  2. Only credits that meet strict standards for additionality, permanence, and independent verification are eligible.
  3. Credits generated by projects under common ownership, control, or financial interest with the liable entity cannot be used to meet that entity’s own obligation.
  4. Methods that issue credits beyond what can be supported by evidence are excluded from compliance use.
  5. Credit issuance rules must prevent the creation of credits that are not backed by real and lasting carbon sequestration.

Quarterly liability and shortfall mechanism

  1. Liable entities must surrender sufficient credits at the end of each quarter.
  2. Any uncovered emissions at quarter-end trigger a shortfall charge equal to twice the official benchmark market price of a credit, subject to an indexed ceiling of $1000 per tonne.
  3. Payment of the shortfall charge does not extinguish the liability.
  4. Each uncovered tonne becomes a mandatory carry-forward surrender obligation that is added to the next quarter’s liability.
  5. If a shortfall persists into the next reporting period, it is again subject to the shortfall charge at that period’s benchmark price.

This creates compounding cost pressure for non-compliance while preserving the integrity of the one-for-one liability rule.

Protecting system discipline

  1. Credit issuance must align with verified carbon sequestration and cannot expand independently of real atmospheric carbon removal.
  2. Credit origin, ownership history, and surrender use must be publicly disclosed each quarter.
  3. The shortfall charge is not tax-deductible.

System effect

Because every tonne must be matched with a credit, firms face a continuous incentive to either reduce emissions directly or acquire scarce high-integrity credits. If credits are genuinely limited and cannot be self-generated within liability groups, rising prices drive real industrial change.

Quarterly reporting and carry-forward obligations prevent strategic delay while keeping the mechanism simple and predictable.

Implementation outline

Amend safeguard and carbon credit legislation to:

  • Enforce quarterly one-for-one liability.
  • Restrict eligibility to high-integrity Australian credits.
  • Prohibit related-party credit surrender.
  • Establish quarterly benchmark price publication.
  • Define the 2× benchmark shortfall charge with indexed cap.
  • Codify mandatory carry-forward of unsurrendered tonnes.

Member ballot

Not yet open
What you’re deciding

Require large polluters to buy and surrender one high-integrity carbon credit for every tonne of emissions, and prohibit rules that allow weak, over-issued, or self-generated credits to dilute the system and avoid real emissions costs.

Review commitments
Ballot record

Wording: Draft wording (no ballot yet)

Formal voting has not opened yet. Join the discussion or propose a wording amendment while this proposal is in deliberation.

Your vote is identifiable to national administrators and authorised national ballot reviewers. Aggregate results are public; a very small ballot may reveal individual choices. Privacy Policy

Formal amendments

0

Suggest exact changes to a title, summary, commitment or rationale paragraph. Voting on an amendment is separate from voting on the main proposal.

No formal amendments have been proposed yet.

Discussion

0 contributions

Share evidence, ask a question or suggest an improvement. Discussion scores do not count as ballot votes.

Have a perspective on this proposal?

Verified members can sign in to comment or vote on contributions.

Sign in to participate

No contributions yet. Verified members can start the discussion using the form above.

Wording history and sources

1 snapshot

See how the wording has changed and which version was put to a ballot. References below provide background; they do not by themselves establish prior adoption.

  1. Original recorded wording · 27 Oct 2026legacy-9Latest
    27 Oct 2026 · Initial wording

Policy background and sources

References to earlier policy and notes about what is known of its history.

Mapping unverified

Not badged 'New' in the static export, but no provenance mapping to prior approved Fusion policy wording has been recorded in the repository.

Scrutiny note: Absence of a 'New' badge in the static export is not treated as evidence of prior approval or material equivalence.