POL-044Renew Our DemocracyPolicy proposal

Break Up Media Monopolies

Amend media ownership and competition law to require divestiture or structural separation where a media corporation exceeds defined national or regional concentration thresholds across news and information markets.

Taking partSign in to save your vote.
  1. Idea
  2. Discussion
  3. Voting
  4. Implementation

Voting is open.

Proposed by
Fusion Working Group
Applies to
Fusion NationalAuthority: Fusion National
Ballot wording
Original recorded wording · 27 Oct 202610 ballots cast · 2 contributions
Policy Registry
Not yet adoptedUpdated

Key commitments

7 commitments
  1. Audiences will have access to a wider range of news sources, editorial priorities, and local reporting voices.

  2. Journalists and editors will face fewer structural pressures to align with the political or commercial priorities of a single dominant owner.

  3. Local communities will be less likely to lose coverage when concentrated ownership treats regional reporting as expendable.

  4. Independent and smaller publishers will have a fairer chance to survive where access to audiences is no longer dominated by a narrow group of incumbent owners.

  5. Public debate will become less vulnerable to coordinated agenda-setting by corporations with outsized control over information channels.

  6. Media markets will compete more on trust, quality, and relevance when ownership concentration can no longer substitute for genuine audience support.

  7. Democratic accountability will strengthen when political actors face scrutiny from a broader and less concentrated press environment.

Rationale & background

Rationale & background

Design rationale

Media concentration carries political and cultural power beyond ordinary commercial scale because control over information channels shapes what audiences see, what issues remain visible, and which voices can reach the public at all. We would stop ownership concentration itself from becoming a durable source of influence regardless of journalistic quality or public trust.

Ownership control framework

  1. The framework depends on defined national and regional concentration thresholds because media influence can accumulate differently across broadcast, print, and digital news markets, and because dominance in a regional market can be as significant as broad national reach.
  2. Divestiture and structural separation matter because the underlying problem is concentrated ownership and coordinated control, not merely isolated anti-competitive conduct. Once concentration exceeds the permitted level, the market structure itself must change rather than being managed only through ongoing behavioural conditions.

Pluralism and democratic resilience

  1. A highly concentrated media environment can allow a small number of owners to shape issue salience, political narratives, and public attention across large parts of the country even where audiences retain formal choice between outlets. Structural separation reduces the ability of a single corporate group to exercise that level of coordinated influence across multiple channels at once.
  2. More dispersed ownership does not guarantee high-quality journalism on its own, but it does reduce the risk that editorial direction, local coverage decisions, and access to audiences are controlled by a narrow set of commercial interests. That wider distribution of control creates more space for independent editorial judgement, new entrants, and regional diversity.

Risk and failure modes

  1. Media groups may be expected to use cross-holdings, affiliates, licensing arrangements, or platform partnerships to preserve effective control while appearing to comply formally with ownership limits. Integrity depends on whether the rule follows substantive control and influence rather than narrow legal ownership alone.
  2. The framework can also underperform if concentration thresholds are set too loosely, if digital news distribution is excluded from meaningful assessment, or if divested assets are transferred into nominally separate entities that remain commercially dependent on the original group. Effective structural separation depends on strong control tests and credible post-separation independence requirements.

System interaction

This measure interacts with general competition law, media ownership rules, and platform regulation, because concentration in news and information markets is shaped not only by formal ownership structures but also by distribution access, advertising markets, and cross-platform audience control.

Implementation outline

Legislation would define the covered media classes, concentration metrics for national and regional assessment, control tests that trigger divestiture or structural separation, and conditions for post-separation independence, supported by regulator powers to investigate coordinated ownership structures and enforce compliance.

Member ballot

Ballot open
What you’re deciding

Amend media ownership and competition law to require divestiture or structural separation where a media corporation exceeds defined national or regional concentration thresholds across news and information markets.

Review commitments
Ballot record

Wording: Original recorded wording · 27 Oct 2026

How many people need to vote?

Quorum met

Engage needs at least 30 eligible registered members before its ballots can make decisions. Each ballot also needs enough people to take part.

Eligible registered members
37 · platform quorum met
Recently active members
14 in the last 90 days
Participants needed
7
Votes recorded so far
10 of 7 needed

You can vote for, vote against or abstain. All three count towards participation. The final calculation happens when voting closes, so the number needed can change as members become active or inactive.

10 votes have been recorded. Sign in to vote if you are eligible.

Your ballotSelect to preview
Voting closes 8 December 2026

Select Approve, Abstain, or Reject above to start your ballot.

Vote totals

10 verified votes

9 approve · 0 abstain · 1 reject

Your vote is identifiable to national administrators and authorised national ballot reviewers. Aggregate results are public; a very small ballot may reveal individual choices. Privacy Policy

Formal amendments

0

Suggest exact changes to a title, summary, commitment or rationale paragraph. Voting on an amendment is separate from voting on the main proposal.

No formal amendments have been proposed yet.

Discussion

2 contributions

Share evidence, ask a question or suggest an improvement. Discussion scores do not count as ballot votes.

Have a perspective on this proposal?

Verified members can sign in to comment or vote on contributions.

Sign in to participate
  1. KL
    Kay LefevreWording

    Public broadcasters are not included. They are already heavily regulated by the Acts.

    1
  2. JB
    Jeff BeuComment

    I think this would draw the ire of the media to the Fusion Party and better just to leave it naturally die out. I think it better to focus on manipulation via FEEDs.

    0

Wording history and sources

1 snapshot

See how the wording has changed and which version was put to a ballot. References below provide background; they do not by themselves establish prior adoption.

  1. Original recorded wording · 27 Oct 2026legacy-9LatestBallot wording
    27 Oct 2026 · Initial wording

Policy background and sources

References to earlier policy and notes about what is known of its history.

Materially revised or submission/FAQ-derived

Adapts or expands prior Fusion policy, submissions, or state-level positions with new or materially revised mechanisms.

Scrutiny note: Cited antecedents do not establish approval of the new or expanded mechanism wording; requires AGM member review and ballot approval.

Prior policy predecessors

Values & principles alignment

  • Principle: *Democratic Reform* — Reducing media concentration broadens the range of voices shaping public debate.
  • Value: *Personal Liberty* — A less concentrated media landscape makes it easier to encounter independent viewpoints.