Current policyReclaim our democracyPower to People

Citizens in Every Room

Use representative citizens’ panels for major, genuinely contested long-term questions to improve deliberation and scrutiny—without creating a parallel legislature or another veto point for routine housing and infrastructure delivery.

Adopted byFusion VictoriaApplies toFusion VictoriaIn force since26 June 2026
Sign in to propose a changeAmend, replace or repeal this policy through a member proposal.

Adopted by the Fusion Victoria executive before this record was imported into Engage. Source: the original published policy ↗.

Key commitments
  • Deliberation where it adds value
  • Evidence before recommendation
  • Advice with accountability
Policy detail

Public consultation should mean more than collecting submissions after the important choices have already been made.

Use representative citizens’ panels for major, genuinely contested long-term questions to improve deliberation and scrutiny—without creating a parallel legislature or another veto point for routine housing and infrastructure delivery.

What it does

  • Deliberation where it adds value — Convene stratified citizens’ panels for selected major long-term or institutionally difficult questions, not every Bill or routine administrative decision.
  • Evidence before recommendation — Give participants balanced evidence, competing expert views and enough time to deliberate, with transparent rules for question design and facilitation.
  • Advice with accountability — Panels make public recommendations and Parliament or government must formally respond; elected institutions remain responsible for the final decision unless a separate lawful referendum is required.

Design Rationale

Sortition can bring people who are not lobbyists, party officials or habitual consultation participants into difficult public decisions. Its value is deliberative: a representative group can examine evidence, trade-offs and competing interests in depth. That does not justify inserting a citizens’ panel into every Bill, planning permit or infrastructure approval. Used selectively, panels can improve legitimacy and expose blind spots without becoming a parallel legislature or an additional mechanism for delaying routine delivery.

System Interaction

Establish a statutory framework allowing Parliament or government to convene stratified citizens’ panels for defined major questions. The remit, selection method, evidence process, funding and conflicts must be public. Recommendations are published and require a formal government or parliamentary response within a set period. Panels do not replace Parliament, courts, independent regulators or ordinary by-right planning rules, and are not required for routine development approvals or delivery of infrastructure already authorised under general law.

Economic & Institutional Logic

Well-designed deliberation can reduce the cost of poorly framed major reforms by exposing trade-offs before positions harden. But mandatory deliberation on routine decisions would itself create delay and transaction costs. A selective model concentrates the process where uncertainty, distributional conflict or long-term institutional consequences justify the additional time.

Risk & Failure Modes

Panels can be manipulated through question framing, participant selection, facilitator bias or selective evidence, and can be misused to launder a decision already made. They can also become a new veto or delay mechanism if applied indiscriminately. Require independent stratified selection, balanced evidence, publication of materials and dissent, transparent funding and facilitation, and a tightly defined remit. Recommendations should inform accountable decision-makers rather than silently displace them.

Evidence & Precedent

Ireland's Citizens' Assembly (2016-18) was established by Dail resolution with 99 members, one randomly selected chairperson and 98 randomly selected citizens stratified by age, gender, and regional distribution. It produced recommendations on abortion law reform that led directly to the 2018 referendum in which 66.4% voted to repeal the Eighth Amendment. The same assembly produced recommendations on climate action, fixed-term parliaments, and ageing, all of which resulted in policy or legislative responses. Paris's participatory budgeting program allocated EUR 100 million in city capital spending to projects chosen by residents voting directly through a digital platform, with 77,000 participants in 2014 growing to over 100,000 in subsequent cycles. Porto Alegre's participatory budgeting, which ran from 1989 to the mid-2000s, allocated up to 21% of the municipal budget through neighbourhood assemblies and distributed elected delegates, producing documented improvements in sewerage, road paving, and schools in lower-income areas.

Implementation Outline

Legislate a common integrity framework for citizens’ panels and pilot it on a small number of major statewide questions. Publish selection methodology, evidence, recommendations, minority views and the formal government response. Independently evaluate representativeness and influence before expanding use.

What it costs

Assembly recruitment, accessibility, facilitation and reporting require funding

Paid for by

Fund citizen assemblies through an explicit public appropriation, with scope and cost published before rollout.

Imported wording revision: rev-vic-citizens-in-every-room-ccf1a4fe9ba6

Adoption record and sources
Policy identifier
vic-citizens-in-every-room
How it was adopted
Imported from Imported from Fusion Party Victoria; adopted by the branch executive.
Source proposal
No source proposal recorded.
Ballot result
No Engage ballot recorded
Authority
Fusion Victoria
Decision event
Not recorded
Ratified
Not ratified through Engage
Effective
26 June 2026
Published
15 November 2026
Provenance
Imported from Fusion Party Victoria
Import basis
Adopted by the Victorian branch executive. Confirmed by the Engage maintainer on 2026-11-15 that all live Victorian branch policies are ratified and adopted.
Imported
15 November 2026
Source record
citizens-in-every-room
Adopted amendments
None recorded
Published wording revisions
rev-vic-citizens-in-every-room-ccf1a4fe9ba6
← Fusion Victoria policy