EC

Ethan Cornwill

National member · Fusion Victoria

Member since 27 Oct 2026

Comments

  1. Comment0 points

    Replied in End Housing Speculation Incentives

    Yep, as noted in the provenance section. The purpose of Engage isn't just to introduce new policies. We're replacing the existing policy platform with the new Reclaim structure, so even existing positions need to be adopted into that structure through a member vote. This proposal carries forward the existing position on negative gearing, rather than introducing an entirely new one.

    View comment

  2. Amendment0 points

    Commented on Match Migration to What Australia Can Support

    **Amendment: Prioritise Capacity Expansion Over Migration Restriction** I support the introduction of an independently assessed, transparent framework for population and infrastructure planning, particularly the additional accountability and funded capacity planning requirements proposed by Stewart. However, I am concerned that POL-050 currently frames migration primarily as a demand variable to be adjusted against existing capacity, rather than recognising that capacity is itself a policy variable governments can and should expand. I propose strengthening the policy with the following principles: 1. **Supply-first planning:** Identified capacity constraints should primarily trigger measures to expand housing, infrastructure, essential services and workforce capacity, rather than reductions in migration. 2. **Dynamic capacity assessment:** Independent assessments must account for the contribution migrants make to expanding productive capacity, including construction, healthcare, education and infrastructure delivery. 3. **Government accountability:** Capacity plans must distinguish between unavoidable short-term constraints and shortages attributable to policy failures, underinvestment or regulatory barriers. Governments should be required to identify remedies for these failures. 4. **Proportional demand management:** Temporary adjustments to migration settings should be considered only where substantial, evidenced constraints cannot reasonably be addressed through timely supply-side or settlement measures, with appropriate safeguards for humanitarian obligations and family unity. 5. **Residency and citizenship distinction:** Migration planning should recognise that the right to reside and participate economically in Australia is conceptually distinct from the acquisition of Australian citizenship, and should support broad, accessible pathways to lawful residency. **Intended outcome** The absorptive-capacity framework would remain, but its primary purpose would shift from determining how much migration Australia can tolerate to identifying what Australia must build, reform and invest in to support an open, growing and prosperous society.

    View comment

  3. Amendment1 point

    Commented on Supply Integrated Public Housing at Scale

    I think the acquisition mechanism could benefit from some clarification. As currently worded, the first right of purchase over one residential floor could be interpreted as either a minimum entitlement or a fixed limit. My reading is that the intention is closer to a minimum, but we should make that explicit. David Balding also raised a reasonable concern about proportionality. One floor in a four-storey development is substantially different from one floor in a twenty-storey development. I'd suggest clarifying that: - One floor represents a minimum acquisition entitlement, not a ceiling. - The acquisition proportion can scale with development size, local housing needs and project viability. - Purchases occur at independently assessed market value, with a transparent valuation and dispute resolution mechanism. - The program complements rather than replaces other public and community housing delivery models, including government-owned land developments. The underlying objective of integrating public housing into mixed communities near transport and employment remains unchanged. This would simply make the mechanism more flexible, predictable and responsive to different development contexts. It may also be worth considering whether a percentage-based entitlement, potentially combined with a minimum floor requirement, would achieve the intended outcomes more consistently.

    View comment